Intelligent Agent Foundations Forumsign up / log in
New circumstances, new values?
discussion post by Stuart Armstrong 134 days ago | discuss

A putative new idea for AI control; index here.

Quick, is there anything wrong with a ten minute pleasant low-intensity conversation with someone we happen to disagree with?

Our moral intuitions say no, as do our legal system and most philosophical or political ideals since the enlightenment.

Quick, is there anything wrong with brainwashing people into perfectly obedient sheep, willing and eager to take any orders and betray all their previous ideals?

There’s a bit more disagreement there, but that generally is seen as a bad thing.

But what happens when the low-intensity conversation and the brainwashing are the same thing? At the moment, no human can overwhelm most other humans in the course of ten minutes talking, and rewrite their goals into anything else. But an AI may well be capable of doing so - people have certainly fallen in love within less than ten minutes, and we don’t know how “hard” this is to pull off, in some absolute sense.

This is a warning that relying on revealed and stated preferences or meta-preferences won’t be enough. Our revealed and (most) stated preferences are that the ten minute conversation is probably ok. But disentangling how much of that “ok” relies on our understanding the consequences will be a challenge.



NEW LINKS

NEW POSTS

NEW DISCUSSION POSTS

RECENT COMMENTS

What does the Law of Logical
by Alex Appel on Smoking Lesion Steelman III: Revenge of the Tickle... | 0 likes

To quote the straw vulcan:
by Stuart Armstrong on Hyperreal Brouwer | 0 likes

I intend to cross-post often.
by Scott Garrabrant on Should I post technical ideas here or on LessWrong... | 1 like

I think technical research
by Vadim Kosoy on Should I post technical ideas here or on LessWrong... | 2 likes

I am much more likely to miss
by Abram Demski on Should I post technical ideas here or on LessWrong... | 1 like

Note that the problem with
by Vadim Kosoy on Open Problems Regarding Counterfactuals: An Introd... | 0 likes

Typos on page 5: *
by Vadim Kosoy on Open Problems Regarding Counterfactuals: An Introd... | 0 likes

Ah, you're right. So gain
by Abram Demski on Smoking Lesion Steelman | 0 likes

> Do you have ideas for how
by Jessica Taylor on Autopoietic systems and difficulty of AGI alignmen... | 0 likes

I think I understand what
by Wei Dai on Autopoietic systems and difficulty of AGI alignmen... | 0 likes

>You don’t have to solve
by Wei Dai on Autopoietic systems and difficulty of AGI alignmen... | 0 likes

Your confusion is because you
by Vadim Kosoy on Delegative Inverse Reinforcement Learning | 0 likes

My confusion is the
by Tom Everitt on Delegative Inverse Reinforcement Learning | 0 likes

> First of all, it seems to
by Abram Demski on Smoking Lesion Steelman | 0 likes

> figure out what my values
by Vladimir Slepnev on Autopoietic systems and difficulty of AGI alignmen... | 0 likes

RSS

Privacy & Terms