by Stuart Armstrong 126 days ago | link | parent but the agent incorrectly observes the action It’s a bit annoying that this has to rely on an incorrect observation. Why not replace the human action, in state $$s_2$$, with a simple automated system that chooses $$a_1^H$$? It’s an easy mistake to make while programming, and the agent has no fundamental understanding of the difference between the human and an imperfect automated system. Basically, if the human acts in perfect accordance with their preferences, and if the agent correctly observes and learns this, the agent will converge on the right values. You put wireheading by removing “correctly observes”, but I think removing “human acts in perfect accordance with their preferences” is a better example for wireheading.

 by Tom Everitt 44 days ago | link Adversarial examples for neural networks make situations where the agent misinterprets the human action seem plausible. But it is true that the situation where the human acts irrationally in some state (e.g. because of drugs, propaganda) could be modeled in much the same way. I preferred the sensory error since it doesn’t require a irrational human. Perhaps I should have been clearer that I’m interested in the agent wireheading itself (in some sense) rather than wireheading of the human. (Sorry for being slow to reply – I didn’t get notified about the comments.) reply

### NEW DISCUSSION POSTS

Note that the problem with
 by Vadim Kosoy on Open Problems Regarding Counterfactuals: An Introd... | 0 likes

Typos on page 5: *
 by Vadim Kosoy on Open Problems Regarding Counterfactuals: An Introd... | 0 likes

Ah, you're right. So gain
 by Abram Demski on Smoking Lesion Steelman | 0 likes

> Do you have ideas for how
 by Jessica Taylor on Autopoietic systems and difficulty of AGI alignmen... | 0 likes

I think I understand what
 by Wei Dai on Autopoietic systems and difficulty of AGI alignmen... | 0 likes

>You don’t have to solve
 by Wei Dai on Autopoietic systems and difficulty of AGI alignmen... | 0 likes

 by Vadim Kosoy on Delegative Inverse Reinforcement Learning | 0 likes

My confusion is the
 by Tom Everitt on Delegative Inverse Reinforcement Learning | 0 likes

> First of all, it seems to
 by Abram Demski on Smoking Lesion Steelman | 0 likes

> figure out what my values
 by Vladimir Slepnev on Autopoietic systems and difficulty of AGI alignmen... | 0 likes

I agree that selection bias
 by Jessica Taylor on Autopoietic systems and difficulty of AGI alignmen... | 0 likes

>It seems quite plausible
 by Wei Dai on Autopoietic systems and difficulty of AGI alignmen... | 0 likes

> defending against this type
 by Paul Christiano on Autopoietic systems and difficulty of AGI alignmen... | 0 likes

2. I think that we can avoid
 by Paul Christiano on Autopoietic systems and difficulty of AGI alignmen... | 0 likes

I hope you stay engaged with
 by Wei Dai on Autopoietic systems and difficulty of AGI alignmen... | 0 likes