Intelligent Agent Foundations Forumsign up / log in
by Paul Christiano 559 days ago | link | parent

A task AI with limited scope can be replaced, but an optimizer has to be able to understand what is being asked of it, and if it wasn’t designed to be able to understand certain things, it won’t be possible to direct it correctly.

It’s not clear to me why “limited scope” and “can be replaced” are related. An agent with broad scope can still be optimizing something like “what the human would want me to do today” and the human could have preferences like “now that humans believe that an alternative design would have been better, gracefully step aside.” (And an agent with narrow scope could be unwilling to step aside if so doing would interfere with accomplishing its narrow task.)



by Vladimir Nesov 559 days ago | link

Being able to “gracefully step aside” (to be replaced) is an example of what I meant by “limited scope” (in time). Even if AI’s scope is “broad”, the crucial point is that it’s not literally everything (and by default it is). In practice it shouldn’t be more than a small part of the future, so that the rest can be optimized better, using new insights. (Also, to be able to ask what humans would want today, there should remain some humans who didn’t get “optimized” into something else.)

reply



NEW LINKS

NEW POSTS

NEW DISCUSSION POSTS

RECENT COMMENTS

There should be a chat icon
by Alex Mennen on Meta: IAFF vs LessWrong | 0 likes

Apparently "You must be
by Jessica Taylor on Meta: IAFF vs LessWrong | 1 like

There is a replacement for
by Alex Mennen on Meta: IAFF vs LessWrong | 1 like

Regarding the physical
by Vadim Kosoy on The Learning-Theoretic AI Alignment Research Agend... | 0 likes

I think that we should expect
by Vadim Kosoy on The Learning-Theoretic AI Alignment Research Agend... | 0 likes

I think I understand your
by Jessica Taylor on The Learning-Theoretic AI Alignment Research Agend... | 0 likes

This seems like a hack. The
by Jessica Taylor on The Learning-Theoretic AI Alignment Research Agend... | 0 likes

After thinking some more,
by Vadim Kosoy on The Learning-Theoretic AI Alignment Research Agend... | 0 likes

Yes, I think that we're
by Vadim Kosoy on The Learning-Theoretic AI Alignment Research Agend... | 0 likes

My intuition is that it must
by Vadim Kosoy on The Learning-Theoretic AI Alignment Research Agend... | 0 likes

To first approximation, a
by Vadim Kosoy on The Learning-Theoretic AI Alignment Research Agend... | 0 likes

Actually, I *am* including
by Vadim Kosoy on The Learning-Theoretic AI Alignment Research Agend... | 0 likes

Yeah, when I went back and
by Alex Appel on Optimal and Causal Counterfactual Worlds | 0 likes

> Well, we could give up on
by Jessica Taylor on The Learning-Theoretic AI Alignment Research Agend... | 0 likes

> For another thing, consider
by Jessica Taylor on The Learning-Theoretic AI Alignment Research Agend... | 0 likes

RSS

Privacy & Terms